The Township of Muskoka Lakes is seeking public input on the state of its 10 fire stations.
Staff are undertaking a fire station location study, as part of the Fire Master Plan, which aims to ensure the fire station network can safely, efficiently, and sustainably meet the needs of a growing and evolving community for the next 25 years.
Launched in 2023 in collaboration with expert consultants, Emergency Management Group Inc. (EMG), the study found that eight stations are nearing the end of their typical 40-year service life.
The study also found space limitations, which have resulted in the use of temporary shelters and the need to purchase custom-sized vehicles.
In addition, the study shows many stations require health and safety upgrades to meet current standards, and there is a geographic overlap where multiple stations cover the same areas, which reduces overall efficiency.
“Our commitment is clear, we will not compromise community safety,” said Ryan Murrell, Fire Chief at the Muskoka Lakes Fire Department. “This study shows we can maintain service levels while modernizing facilities, reducing geographic overlap, and investing in better infrastructure for our firefighters and community.”
As a result of the study, three main options were identified for the fire station network.
The first option, which is the current one, is to maintain the current 10-station network, with plans to rebuild stations over time at existing or nearby locations.
This option involves capital costs for buildings and trucks of $64,217,701 over a 20-year period and $166,424,535 over 40 years.
The second option, which is recommended by the consultant and staff, is to consolidate into a 7-station model. This would involve closing three stations, modernizing two, and rebuilding four to reduce overlap and allow for reinvestment in high-quality facilities.
This option involves capital costs for buildings and trucks of $55,245,595 over a 20-year period and $93,221,810 over 40 years.
The third option is a 5-station model that would require decommissioning all current stations and constructing five new ones in new locations.
This option involves capital costs for buildings and trucks of $59,719,363 over a 20-year period and $91,106,548 over 40 years.
According to the report presented to council on Aug. 13, the funding strategy for each option includes debt financing, grant opportunities, sponsorship and community fundraising, and reserves and asset replacement funds.
Community members who want to provide feedback on the latest phase of the Fire Station Location Study can review the report and submit their comments online.
The Township will be accepting feedback until September 26.
