The Muskoka Lumber Community Centre has roof deficiencies that could cost nearly $1.1 million to repair.
According to Rick Cox, director of recreation, the roof of the $75-million building, which opened to the public in August 2024, sustained damage from a significant snow load during the winter of 2024-25.
“Since then there has been deterioration, there’s been movement, there’s been shifting within the roof structure on the arena and field house, and that has caused some leaks, has caused some damage to the exterior roof pieces, and there is a risk that the sections of the roof are not properly attached to each other,” said Cox.
During the Sept. 1 general committee meeting, Cox said they have been discussing with the engineers, the subcontractors, and the contractor what the exact cause is and who is responsible for fixing it.
“Contractors have suggested that perhaps it’s related to building movement; engineers and architects are suggesting that that’s not the case, but that’s what the discussion is, and we’re having to defend our position,” he said.
Cox said a portion of the allocation is for the ongoing architectural, engineering, and legal expertise needed to ensure the fieldhouse, arena and lobby roof deficiencies are properly and finally rectified.
“We have paid for a roof which not only doesn’t leak but also has certain characteristics in terms of longevity and lifespan, and our expectation is that that is what we get delivered,” said Cox.
Cox said the insurance claim, which has been approved and is still being processed, will cover $430,000, less than half of the total costs.
He said the proposed fixes and improvements are primarily aimed at enhancing the library roof and parapet performance and resilience during significant snowfall events.
“I am frustrated with the finger-pointing that’s going on and the time it has taken, and I on a regular basis make that point known to all concerned,” said Cox. “That has not yet translated into mobilization of the fix just yet.”
Cox said they will continue to assess all available avenues to offset project costs and minimize the net financial impact to the Town.
Staff said they will provide an update to council at a future meeting.
